SPOILERS!I enjoyed reading this book - I was pleasantly surprised by Hilary's novel.The main issue I had with it was, that I predicted so much of the story. I felt that the story line almost identical to another book I have read, Evermore: an immortal guy who is continuously drawn to his soul mate's reincarnations time and time again. However the soulmate is always killed by a jealous other, in this case by a soul who is included in the equation, and in the other book I am talking about there is also the third soul drawn to the main character. This made the novel way to predictable for me.